Online reviews can help you form an agent shortlist, but star ratings alone do not explain how an agent works. Look for specific accounts of communication, negotiation, organization, and follow-through.

Read across more than one source

Compare reviews on real estate portals, general business directories, and the agent's own website. Notice dates and whether reviewers describe transactions similar to yours. A detailed account of a difficult closing may be more informative than a dozen short compliments.

Turn reviews into interview questions

If clients praise responsiveness, ask how updates are handled and who covers when the agent is unavailable. If a review mentions a problem, ask respectfully about the process used to resolve concerns. Public responses should protect client privacy rather than reveal transaction details.

Verify licensing independently and request references when useful. Reviews are one input; your own conversation should establish the agent's experience, services, compensation, and ability to explain decisions clearly before you sign a representation agreement.